When J.C. Penney hired Apple executive Ron Johnson to lead a bold transformation, the strategy looked great on paper. He scrapped constant discounting in favour of everyday low prices, redesigned stores, and aimed to create a more premium experience.
But there was one major problem: their customers weren’t ready for it. The people who shopped there liked the coupons, the sales racks, the bargain hunt. And the staff — many of whom had spent years operating one way — didn’t understand how to sell in this new model.
The strategy wasn’t inherently wrong. But it failed to account for the human response. Sales plummeted, and within 18 months, Johnson was out.
It’s a common occurrence, strategies that look great on paper until they hit real people in the real world. We all know the patterns: resistance, misunderstandings, ‘this is just another initiative’, ‘that will never work here’.
But here’s the thing, no one knows your people and culture better than this group. The same leaders who will drive these changes also hold the insights you need to anticipate what might slow you down, and plan for it now, not later.
Think of this as mental rehearsal: if you can predict the challenges, you can prepare to overcome them.